text/appendixes/comparing_defs.tex
changeset 967 6e4f0ed47e0e
parent 966 d9e4d7e1cbf6
child 969 2232d94b90b8
equal deleted inserted replaced
966:d9e4d7e1cbf6 967:6e4f0ed47e0e
   677 	\draw (p1) .. controls +(1,-2) and +(-1,-1) .. (pd);
   677 	\draw (p1) .. controls +(1,-2) and +(-1,-1) .. (pd);
   678 	\draw (p2) .. controls +(-1,2) and +(1,1) .. (pu);
   678 	\draw (p2) .. controls +(-1,2) and +(1,1) .. (pu);
   679 	\draw[->, thick, orange!50!brown] (1.45,-1.1)--  node[left, black] {$f$} +(0,.7);
   679 	\draw[->, thick, orange!50!brown] (1.45,-1.1)--  node[left, black] {$f$} +(0,.7);
   680 	\draw[->, thick, orange!50!brown] (4.35,.4)--  node[left, black] {$g$} +(0,.7);
   680 	\draw[->, thick, orange!50!brown] (4.35,.4)--  node[left, black] {$g$} +(0,.7);
   681 	\draw[->, thick, blue!75!yellow] (1.5,.78) node[black, above] {$(b\cdot c)\times I$} -- (2.5,0);
   681 	\draw[->, thick, blue!75!yellow] (1.5,.78) node[black, above] {$(b\cdot c)\times I$} -- (2.5,0);
   682 \end{tikzpicture}} \\
   682 \end{tikzpicture}} \displaybreak[1] \\
   683 \;&=\;
   683 \;&=\;
   684 \raisebox{-2.1cm}{
   684 \raisebox{-2.1cm}{
   685 \begin{tikzpicture}
   685 \begin{tikzpicture}
   686 	\draw (0,0) coordinate (p1);
   686 	\draw (0,0) coordinate (p1);
   687 	\draw (5.8,0) coordinate (p2);
   687 	\draw (5.8,0) coordinate (p2);
   703 	\draw (p1) .. controls +(1,1) and +(-1,1) .. (pu);
   703 	\draw (p1) .. controls +(1,1) and +(-1,1) .. (pu);
   704 	\draw (p2) .. controls +(-1,1) and +(1,1) .. (pu);
   704 	\draw (p2) .. controls +(-1,1) and +(1,1) .. (pu);
   705 	\draw[->, thick, orange!50!brown] (1.45,-0.1)--  node[left, black] {$f$} +(0,.7);
   705 	\draw[->, thick, orange!50!brown] (1.45,-0.1)--  node[left, black] {$f$} +(0,.7);
   706 	\draw[->, thick, orange!50!brown] (4.35,-0.1)--  node[left, black] {$g$} +(0,.7);
   706 	\draw[->, thick, orange!50!brown] (4.35,-0.1)--  node[left, black] {$g$} +(0,.7);
   707 	\draw[->, thick, blue!75!yellow] (4.3,-1.5) node[black, below] {$(a\cdot c)\times I$} -- (3.3,-0.5);
   707 	\draw[->, thick, blue!75!yellow] (4.3,-1.5) node[black, below] {$(a\cdot c)\times I$} -- (3.3,-0.5);
   708 \end{tikzpicture}} \\
   708 \end{tikzpicture}} \displaybreak[1] \\
   709 \;&=\;
   709 \;&=\;
   710 \raisebox{-1.9cm}{
   710 \raisebox{-1.9cm}{
   711 \begin{tikzpicture}[y=-1cm]
   711 \begin{tikzpicture}[y=-1cm]
   712 	\draw (0,0) coordinate (p1);
   712 	\draw (0,0) coordinate (p1);
   713 	\draw (5.8,0) coordinate (p2);
   713 	\draw (5.8,0) coordinate (p2);
   729 	\draw (p1) .. controls +(1,-2) and +(-1,-1) .. (pd);
   729 	\draw (p1) .. controls +(1,-2) and +(-1,-1) .. (pd);
   730 	\draw (p2) .. controls +(-1,2) and +(1,1) .. (pu);
   730 	\draw (p2) .. controls +(-1,2) and +(1,1) .. (pu);
   731 	\draw[<-, thick, orange!50!brown] (1.45,-1.1)--  node[left, black] {$f$} +(0,.7);
   731 	\draw[<-, thick, orange!50!brown] (1.45,-1.1)--  node[left, black] {$f$} +(0,.7);
   732 	\draw[<-, thick, orange!50!brown] (4.35,.4)--  node[left, black] {$g$} +(0,.7);
   732 	\draw[<-, thick, orange!50!brown] (4.35,.4)--  node[left, black] {$g$} +(0,.7);
   733 	\draw[->, thick, blue!75!yellow] (1.5,.78) node[black, below] {$(a\cdot d)\times I$} -- (2.5,0);
   733 	\draw[->, thick, blue!75!yellow] (1.5,.78) node[black, below] {$(a\cdot d)\times I$} -- (2.5,0);
   734 \end{tikzpicture}} \\
   734 \end{tikzpicture}} \displaybreak[1] \\
   735 \;&=\;
   735 \;&=\;
   736 \raisebox{-1.0cm}{
   736 \raisebox{-1.0cm}{
   737 \begin{tikzpicture}[y=-1cm]
   737 \begin{tikzpicture}[y=-1cm]
   738 	\draw (0,0) coordinate (p1);
   738 	\draw (0,0) coordinate (p1);
   739 	\draw (5.8,0) coordinate (p2);
   739 	\draw (5.8,0) coordinate (p2);
   930 (Both are 2-morphisms from $(a\bullet \id_y)\bullet b$ to $a\bullet b$.)
   930 (Both are 2-morphisms from $(a\bullet \id_y)\bullet b$ to $a\bullet b$.)
   931 \begin{figure}[t]
   931 \begin{figure}[t]
   932 \begin{align*}
   932 \begin{align*}
   933 \mathfig{0.4}{triangle/triangle4a} \\
   933 \mathfig{0.4}{triangle/triangle4a} \\
   934 \mathfig{0.4}{triangle/triangle4b} \\
   934 \mathfig{0.4}{triangle/triangle4b} \\
   935 \mathfig{0.4}{triangle/triangle4c} \\
   935 \mathfig{0.4}{triangle/triangle4c}
       
   936 \end{align*}
       
   937 \begin{align*}
   936 \alpha & = 
   938 \alpha & = 
   937 \begin{tikzpicture}[baseline]
   939 \begin{tikzpicture}[baseline]
   938 \node[circle,fill=black,inner sep=1pt] at (1.73,0) {};
   940 \node[circle,fill=black,inner sep=1pt] at (1.73,0) {};
   939 \node[circle,fill=black,inner sep=1pt] at (-1.73,0) {};
   941 \node[circle,fill=black,inner sep=1pt] at (-1.73,0) {};
   940 \begin{scope}[yshift=-1cm]
   942 \begin{scope}[yshift=-1cm]
  1023 Note that here we have used in an essential way the associativity of product morphisms (Axiom \ref{axiom:product}.3) 
  1025 Note that here we have used in an essential way the associativity of product morphisms (Axiom \ref{axiom:product}.3) 
  1024 as well as compatibility of product morphisms with fiber-preserving maps (Axiom \ref{axiom:product}.1).
  1026 as well as compatibility of product morphisms with fiber-preserving maps (Axiom \ref{axiom:product}.1).
  1025 \begin{figure}[t]
  1027 \begin{figure}[t]
  1026 \begin{align*}
  1028 \begin{align*}
  1027 \mathfig{0.4}{triangle/triangle4d}
  1029 \mathfig{0.4}{triangle/triangle4d}
  1028 \mathfig{0.4}{triangle/triangle4e}
  1030 \mathfig{0.4}{triangle/triangle4e} \\
       
  1031 \end{align*}
       
  1032 \begin{align*}
       
  1033 u \bullet (b \times I) & = 
       
  1034 \begin{tikzpicture}[baseline]
       
  1035 \coordinate (L) at (0,0);
       
  1036 \coordinate (R) at (3,0);
       
  1037 \coordinate (T) at (1.5,0.8);
       
  1038 \coordinate (M) at (1.5,-0.4);
       
  1039 \coordinate (B) at (0.75,-0.8);
       
  1040 \path (L) \vertex (T) \vertex (R) \vertex (M) \vertex (B) \vertex;
       
  1041 \draw (L)  to[out=40,in=180] node[above] {$a$} (T) 
       
  1042 		to[out=0,in=140] node[above] {$b$} (R) 
       
  1043 		to[out=-150,in=-20] node[below] {$b$} (M) 
       
  1044 		-- node[below] {\tiny $y \times I$} (B) 
       
  1045 		to[out=150,in=-45] node[below] {$a$} (L);
       
  1046 \draw[dashed] (L) to[out=0,in=150] (M)
       
  1047 			     to[out=30,in=150] (R);
       
  1048 \draw[dashed] (T) -- (M);
       
  1049 \foreach \n in {0,...,7} {
       
  1050 	\path (L) to[out=-45,in=150] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (LB\n) {} (B);
       
  1051 	\path (L) to[out=0,in=150] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (LM\n) {} (M);
       
  1052 	\path (L) to[out=40,in=180] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (LT\n) {} (T);
       
  1053 	\draw[green!50!brown] (LB\n) -- (LM\n) -- (LT\n);
       
  1054 }
       
  1055 \foreach \n in {1,...,7} {
       
  1056 	\path (M) to[out=-20,in=-150] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (MR\n) {} (R);
       
  1057 	\path (T) to[out=0,in=140] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (TR\n) {} (R);
       
  1058 	\draw[brown] (MR\n) -- (TR\n);
       
  1059 }
       
  1060 \end{tikzpicture} \\
       
  1061 (a \times I) \bullet v & = 
       
  1062 \begin{tikzpicture}[baseline]
       
  1063 \coordinate (L) at (0,0);
       
  1064 \coordinate (R) at (3,0);
       
  1065 \coordinate (T) at (1.5,0.8);
       
  1066 \coordinate (M) at (1.5,-0.4);
       
  1067 \coordinate (B) at (2.25,-0.8);
       
  1068 \path (L) \vertex (T) \vertex (R) \vertex (M) \vertex (B) \vertex;
       
  1069 \draw (L)  to[out=40,in=180] node[above] {$a$} (T) 
       
  1070 		to[out=0,in=140] node[above] {$b$} (R)
       
  1071 		to[out=-150,in=45] node[below] {$b$} (B) 
       
  1072 		-- node[below=2] {\tiny $y \times I$} (M) 
       
  1073 		to[out=-160,in=-30] node[below] {$a$} (L);
       
  1074 \draw[dashed] (L) to[out=30,in=150] (M)
       
  1075 			     to[out=30,in=180] (R);
       
  1076 \draw[dashed] (T) -- (M);
       
  1077 \foreach \n in {1,...,7} {
       
  1078 	\path (B) to[out=45,in=-150] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (BR\n) {} (R);
       
  1079 	\path (M) to[out=30,in=180] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (MR\n) {} (R);
       
  1080 	\path (T) to[out=0,in=140] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (TR\n) {} (R);
       
  1081 	\draw[brown] (BR\n) -- (MR\n) -- (TR\n);
       
  1082 }
       
  1083 \foreach \n in {1,...,7} {
       
  1084 	\path (L) to[out=-20,in=-150] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (LM\n) {} (M);
       
  1085 	\path (L) to[out=40,in=180] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (LT\n) {} (T);
       
  1086 	\draw[green!50!brown] (LM\n) -- (LT\n);
       
  1087 }
       
  1088 \end{tikzpicture} 
  1029 \end{align*}
  1089 \end{align*}
  1030 \caption{Horizontal compositions in the triangle axiom.}
  1090 \caption{Horizontal compositions in the triangle axiom.}
  1031 \label{fig:horizontal-composition}
  1091 \label{fig:horizontal-composition}
  1032 \end{figure}
  1092 \end{figure}
  1033 \begin{figure}[t]
  1093 \begin{figure}[t]
  1087 \label{fig:vertical-composition}
  1147 \label{fig:vertical-composition}
  1088 \end{figure}
  1148 \end{figure}
  1089 \begin{figure}[t]
  1149 \begin{figure}[t]
  1090 \begin{align*}
  1150 \begin{align*}
  1091 \mathfig{0.4}{triangle/triangle5}
  1151 \mathfig{0.4}{triangle/triangle5}
       
  1152 \end{align*}
       
  1153 \begin{align*}
       
  1154 \begin{tikzpicture}[baseline]
       
  1155 \coordinate (L) at (0,0);
       
  1156 \coordinate (R) at (3,0);
       
  1157 \coordinate (T) at (1.5,0.8);
       
  1158 \coordinate (M) at (1.5,-0.4);
       
  1159 \coordinate (B) at (0.75,-0.8);
       
  1160 \path (L) \vertex (T) \vertex (R) \vertex (M) \vertex (B) \vertex;
       
  1161 \draw (L)  to[out=40,in=180]  (T) 
       
  1162 		to[out=0,in=140]  (R) 
       
  1163 		to[out=-150,in=-20]  (M) 
       
  1164 		-- (B) 
       
  1165 		to[out=150,in=-45]  (L);
       
  1166 \draw[dashed] (T) -- (M);
       
  1167 \foreach \n in {0,...,7} {
       
  1168 	\path (L) to[out=-45,in=150] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (LB\n) {} (B);
       
  1169 	\path (L) to[out=0,in=150] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (LM\n) {} (M);
       
  1170 	\path (L) to[out=40,in=180] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (LT\n) {} (T);
       
  1171 	\draw[green!50!brown] (LB\n) -- (LM\n) -- (LT\n);
       
  1172 }
       
  1173 \foreach \n in {1,...,7} {
       
  1174 	\path (M) to[out=-20,in=-150] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (MR\n) {} (R);
       
  1175 	\path (T) to[out=0,in=140] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (TR\n) {} (R);
       
  1176 	\draw[brown] (MR\n) -- (TR\n);
       
  1177 }
       
  1178 \coordinate (B') at ($(B)+(0.125,-0.25)$);
       
  1179 \coordinate (M') at ($(M)+(0.125,-0.25)$);
       
  1180 \coordinate (R') at ($(R)+(0.125,-0.25)$);
       
  1181 \coordinate (X) at ($(M')+(0,-0.6)$);
       
  1182 \path (X) \vertex;
       
  1183 \draw[dashed] (M') -- (X);
       
  1184 \draw[clip] (B') to[out=-30,in=180] (X) to[out=0,in=-135] (R') to[out=-150,in=-20] (M') -- cycle;
       
  1185 \foreach \n in {1,...,7} {
       
  1186 	\path (M') to[out=-20,in=-150] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (M'R'\n) {} (R');
       
  1187 	\draw[brown] (M'R'\n) -- +(0,-1);
       
  1188 }
       
  1189 \foreach \n in {1,...,5} {
       
  1190 	\path (B') to[out=-30,in=180] node[coordinate,pos=\n/6] (B'X\n) {} (X);
       
  1191 	\path (M') to[out=-90,in=90] node[coordinate,pos=\n/6] (M'X\n) {} (X);
       
  1192 	\path (B') to[out=30,in=-150] node[coordinate,pos=\n/6] (B'M'\n) {} (M');
       
  1193 	\draw[blue] (B'X\n) -- (M'X\n);
       
  1194 	\draw[blue] (B'M'\n) -- (B'X\n);
       
  1195 }
       
  1196 \end{tikzpicture} 
       
  1197 \xrightarrow{\text{collar}}
       
  1198 \begin{tikzpicture}[baseline]
       
  1199 \coordinate (L) at (0,0);
       
  1200 \coordinate (R) at (3,0);
       
  1201 \coordinate (T) at (1.5,0.8);
       
  1202 \coordinate (M) at (1.5,-0.4);
       
  1203 \coordinate (B) at (0.75,-0.8);
       
  1204 \path (L) \vertex (T) \vertex (R) \vertex (M) \vertex (B) \vertex;
       
  1205 \draw (L)  to[out=40,in=180]  (T) 
       
  1206 		to[out=0,in=140]  (R);
       
  1207 \draw[dashed] (R) to[out=-150,in=-20]  (M) 
       
  1208 		-- (B); 
       
  1209 \draw	(B)	to[out=150,in=-45]  (L);
       
  1210 \draw[dashed] (T) -- (M);
       
  1211 \foreach \n in {0,...,7} {
       
  1212 	\path (L) to[out=-45,in=150] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (LB\n) {} (B);
       
  1213 	\path (L) to[out=0,in=150] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (LM\n) {} (M);
       
  1214 	\path (L) to[out=40,in=180] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (LT\n) {} (T);
       
  1215 	\draw[green!50!brown] (LB\n) -- (LM\n) -- (LT\n);
       
  1216 }
       
  1217 \foreach \n in {1,...,7} {
       
  1218 	\path (M) to[out=-20,in=-150] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (MR\n) {} (R);
       
  1219 	\path (T) to[out=0,in=140] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (TR\n) {} (R);
       
  1220 	\draw[brown] (MR\n) -- (TR\n);
       
  1221 }
       
  1222 \coordinate (B') at (B);
       
  1223 \coordinate (M') at (M);
       
  1224 \coordinate (R') at (R);
       
  1225 \coordinate (X) at ($(M')+(0,-0.6)$);
       
  1226 \path (X) \vertex;
       
  1227 \draw[dashed] (M') -- (X);
       
  1228 \draw (B') to[out=-30,in=180] (X) to[out=0,in=-135] (R');
       
  1229 \path[clip] (B') to[out=-30,in=180] (X) to[out=0,in=-135] (R') to[out=-150,in=-20] (M') -- cycle;
       
  1230 \foreach \n in {1,...,7} {
       
  1231 	\path (M') to[out=-20,in=-150] node[coordinate,pos=\n/8] (M'R'\n) {} (R');
       
  1232 	\draw[brown] (M'R'\n) -- +(0,-1);
       
  1233 }
       
  1234 \foreach \n in {1,...,5} {
       
  1235 	\path (B') to[out=-30,in=180] node[coordinate,pos=\n/6] (B'X\n) {} (X);
       
  1236 	\path (M') to[out=-90,in=90] node[coordinate,pos=\n/6] (M'X\n) {} (X);
       
  1237 	\path (B') to[out=30,in=-150] node[coordinate,pos=\n/6] (B'M'\n) {} (M');
       
  1238 	\draw[blue] (B'X\n) -- (M'X\n);
       
  1239 	\draw[blue] (B'M'\n) -- (B'X\n);
       
  1240 }
       
  1241 \end{tikzpicture} 
  1092 \end{align*}
  1242 \end{align*}
  1093 \caption{Adding a collar in the proof of the triangle axiom.}
  1243 \caption{Adding a collar in the proof of the triangle axiom.}
  1094 \label{fig:adding-a-collar}
  1244 \label{fig:adding-a-collar}
  1095 \end{figure}
  1245 \end{figure}
  1096 
  1246