text/basic_properties.tex
author Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
Tue, 01 Jun 2010 11:34:03 -0700
changeset 314 6e23226d1cca
parent 222 217b6a870532
child 332 160ca7078ae9
permissions -rw-r--r--
various small changes
Ignore whitespace changes - Everywhere: Within whitespace: At end of lines:
100
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
     1
%!TEX root = ../blob1.tex
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
     2
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
     3
\section{Basic properties of the blob complex}
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
     4
\label{sec:basic-properties}
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
     5
314
6e23226d1cca various small changes
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 222
diff changeset
     6
In this section we complete the proofs of Properties 1-5. Throughout the paper, where possible, we prove results using Properties 1-5, rather than the actual definition of blob homology. This allows the possibility of future improvements to or alternatives on our definition. In fact, we hope that there may be a characterisation of blob homology in terms of Properties 1-5, but at this point we are unaware of one.
222
217b6a870532 committing changes from loon lake - mostly small blobs
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 221
diff changeset
     7
217b6a870532 committing changes from loon lake - mostly small blobs
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 221
diff changeset
     8
Recall Property \ref{property:disjoint-union}, that there is a natural isomorphism $\bc_*(X \du Y) \cong \bc_*(X) \otimes \bc_*(Y)$.
217b6a870532 committing changes from loon lake - mostly small blobs
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 221
diff changeset
     9
217b6a870532 committing changes from loon lake - mostly small blobs
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 221
diff changeset
    10
\begin{proof}[Proof of Property \ref{property:disjoint-union}]
100
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    11
Given blob diagrams $b_1$ on $X$ and $b_2$ on $Y$, we can combine them
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    12
(putting the $b_1$ blobs before the $b_2$ blobs in the ordering) to get a
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    13
blob diagram $(b_1, b_2)$ on $X \du Y$.
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    14
Because of the blob reordering relations, all blob diagrams on $X \du Y$ arise this way.
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    15
In the other direction, any blob diagram on $X\du Y$ is equal (up to sign)
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    16
to one that puts $X$ blobs before $Y$ blobs in the ordering, and so determines
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    17
a pair of blob diagrams on $X$ and $Y$.
222
217b6a870532 committing changes from loon lake - mostly small blobs
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 221
diff changeset
    18
These two maps are compatible with our sign conventions.  (We follow the usual convention for tensors products of complexes, as in e.g. \cite{MR1438306}: $d(a \tensor b) = da \tensor b + (-1)^{\deg(a)} a \tensor db$.)
100
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    19
The two maps are inverses of each other.
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    20
\end{proof}
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    21
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    22
For the next proposition we will temporarily restore $n$-manifold boundary
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    23
conditions to the notation.
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    24
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    25
Suppose that for all $c \in \cC(\bd B^n)$
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    26
we have a splitting $s: H_0(\bc_*(B^n, c)) \to \bc_0(B^n; c)$
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    27
of the quotient map
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    28
$p: \bc_0(B^n; c) \to H_0(\bc_*(B^n, c))$.
141
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 100
diff changeset
    29
For example, this is always the case if the coefficient ring is a field.
100
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    30
Then
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    31
\begin{prop} \label{bcontract}
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    32
For all $c \in \cC(\bd B^n)$ the natural map $p: \bc_*(B^n, c) \to H_0(\bc_*(B^n, c))$
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    33
is a chain homotopy equivalence
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    34
with inverse $s: H_0(\bc_*(B^n, c)) \to \bc_*(B^n; c)$.
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    35
Here we think of $H_0(\bc_*(B^n, c))$ as a 1-step complex concentrated in degree 0.
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    36
\end{prop}
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    37
\begin{proof}
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    38
By assumption $p\circ s = \id$, so all that remains is to find a degree 1 map
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    39
$h : \bc_*(B^n; c) \to \bc_*(B^n; c)$ such that $\bd h + h\bd = \id - s \circ p$.
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    40
For $i \ge 1$, define $h_i : \bc_i(B^n; c) \to \bc_{i+1}(B^n; c)$ by adding
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    41
an $(i{+}1)$-st blob equal to all of $B^n$.
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    42
In other words, add a new outermost blob which encloses all of the others.
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    43
Define $h_0 : \bc_0(B^n; c) \to \bc_1(B^n; c)$ by setting $h_0(x)$ equal to
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    44
the 1-blob with blob $B^n$ and label $x - s(p(x)) \in U(B^n; c)$.
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    45
\end{proof}
222
217b6a870532 committing changes from loon lake - mostly small blobs
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 221
diff changeset
    46
This proves Property \ref{property:contractibility} (the second half of the statement of this Property was immediate from the definitions).
217b6a870532 committing changes from loon lake - mostly small blobs
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 221
diff changeset
    47
Note that even when there is no splitting $s$, we can let $h_0 = 0$ and get a homotopy
100
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    48
equivalence to the 2-step complex $U(B^n; c) \to \cC(B^n; c)$.
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    49
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    50
For fields based on $n$-categories, $H_0(\bc_*(B^n; c)) \cong \mor(c', c'')$,
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    51
where $(c', c'')$ is some (any) splitting of $c$ into domain and range.
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    52
221
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    53
\begin{cor} \label{disj-union-contract}
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    54
If $X$ is a disjoint union of $n$-balls, then $\bc_*(X; c)$ is contractible.
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    55
\end{cor}
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    56
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    57
\begin{proof}
222
217b6a870532 committing changes from loon lake - mostly small blobs
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 221
diff changeset
    58
This follows from Properties \ref{property:disjoint-union} and \ref{property:contractibility}.
221
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    59
\end{proof}
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    60
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    61
Define the {\it support} of a blob diagram to be the union of all the 
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    62
blobs of the diagram.
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    63
Define the support of a linear combination of blob diagrams to be the union of the 
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    64
supports of the constituent diagrams.
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    65
For future use we prove the following lemma.
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    66
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    67
\begin{lemma} \label{support-shrink}
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    68
Let $L_* \sub \bc_*(X)$ be a subcomplex generated by some
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    69
subset of the blob diagrams on $X$, and let $f: L_* \to L_*$
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    70
be a chain map which does not increase supports and which induces an isomorphism on
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    71
$H_0(L_*)$.
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    72
Then $f$ is homotopic (in $\bc_*(X)$) to the identity $L_*\to L_*$.
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    73
\end{lemma}
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    74
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    75
\begin{proof}
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    76
We will use the method of acyclic models.
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    77
Let $b$ be a blob diagram of $L_*$, let $S\sub X$ be the support of $b$, and let
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    78
$r$ be the restriction of $b$ to $X\setminus S$.
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    79
Note that $S$ is a disjoint union of balls.
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    80
Assign to $b$ the acyclic (in positive degrees) subcomplex $T(b) \deq r\bullet\bc_*(S)$.
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    81
note that if a diagram $b'$ is part of $\bd b$ then $T(B') \sub T(b)$.
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    82
Both $f$ and the identity are compatible with $T$ (in the sense of acyclic models), 
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    83
so $f$ and the identity map are homotopic.
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    84
\end{proof}
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 141
diff changeset
    85
100
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    86
For the next proposition we will temporarily restore $n$-manifold boundary
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    87
conditions to the notation.
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    88
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    89
Let $X$ be an $n$-manifold, $\bd X = Y \cup (-Y) \cup Z$.
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    90
Gluing the two copies of $Y$ together yields an $n$-manifold $X\sgl$
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    91
with boundary $Z\sgl$.
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    92
Given compatible fields (boundary conditions) $a$, $b$ and $c$ on $Y$, $-Y$ and $Z$,
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    93
we have the blob complex $\bc_*(X; a, b, c)$.
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    94
If $b = -a$ (the orientation reversal of $a$), then we can glue up blob diagrams on
222
217b6a870532 committing changes from loon lake - mostly small blobs
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 221
diff changeset
    95
$X$ to get blob diagrams on $X\sgl$. This proves Property \ref{property:gluing-map}, which we restate here in more detail.
100
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    96
222
217b6a870532 committing changes from loon lake - mostly small blobs
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 221
diff changeset
    97
\textbf{Property \ref{property:gluing-map}.}\emph{
100
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    98
There is a natural chain map
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
    99
\eq{
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   100
    \gl: \bigoplus_a \bc_*(X; a, -a, c) \to \bc_*(X\sgl; c\sgl).
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   101
}
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   102
The sum is over all fields $a$ on $Y$ compatible at their
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   103
($n{-}2$-dimensional) boundaries with $c$.
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   104
`Natural' means natural with respect to the actions of diffeomorphisms.
222
217b6a870532 committing changes from loon lake - mostly small blobs
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 221
diff changeset
   105
}
100
c5a43be00ed4 No new content, just rearranging (and procrastinating)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   106
222
217b6a870532 committing changes from loon lake - mostly small blobs
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 221
diff changeset
   107
This map is very far from being an isomorphism, even on homology.
217b6a870532 committing changes from loon lake - mostly small blobs
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 221
diff changeset
   108
We fix this deficit in Section \ref{sec:gluing} below.
314
6e23226d1cca various small changes
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 222
diff changeset
   109
6e23226d1cca various small changes
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 222
diff changeset
   110
As we pointed out earlier, Property \ref{property:skein-modules} is immediate from the definitions.