text/intro.tex
author Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
Mon, 27 Sep 2010 20:57:02 -0700
changeset 561 77a80f91e214
parent 558 c393d1202724
child 563 d2430f0a14f6
permissions -rw-r--r--
last minute changes from friday, to submit to the arxiv
Ignore whitespace changes - Everywhere: Within whitespace: At end of lines:
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
     1
%!TEX root = ../blob1.tex
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
     2
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
     3
\section{Introduction}
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
     4
481
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
     5
We construct a chain complex $\bc_*(M; \cC)$ --- the ``blob complex'' --- 
536
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 528
diff changeset
     6
associated to an $n$-manifold $M$ and a linear $n$-category $\cC$ with strong duality.
481
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
     7
This blob complex provides a simultaneous generalization of several well known constructions:
147
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 145
diff changeset
     8
\begin{itemize}
481
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
     9
\item The 0-th homology $H_0(\bc_*(M; \cC))$ is isomorphic to the usual 
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
    10
topological quantum field theory invariant of $M$ associated to $\cC$.
550
c9f41c18a96f deleting nn's
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 536
diff changeset
    11
(See Proposition \ref{thm:skein-modules} later in the introduction and \S \ref{sec:constructing-a-tqft}.)
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    12
\item When $n=1$ and $\cC$ is just a 1-category (e.g.\ an associative algebra), 
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    13
the blob complex $\bc_*(S^1; \cC)$ is quasi-isomorphic to the Hochschild complex $\HC_*(\cC)$.
400
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
    14
(See Theorem \ref{thm:hochschild} and \S \ref{sec:hochschild}.)
553
94cadcb4831f killing commutative alg appendix
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 551
diff changeset
    15
%\item When $\cC$ is the polynomial algebra $k[t]$, thought of as an n-category, we have 
94cadcb4831f killing commutative alg appendix
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 551
diff changeset
    16
%that $\bc_*(M; k[t])$ is homotopy equivalent to $C_*(\Sigma^\infty(M), k)$, the singular chains
94cadcb4831f killing commutative alg appendix
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 551
diff changeset
    17
%on the configuration space of unlabeled points in $M$. (See \S \ref{sec:comm_alg}.)
481
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
    18
\item When $\cC$ is $\pi^\infty_{\leq n}(T)$, the $A_\infty$ version of the fundamental $n$-groupoid of
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
    19
the space $T$ (Example \ref{ex:chains-of-maps-to-a-space}), 
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
    20
$\bc_*(M; \cC)$ is homotopy equivalent to $C_*(\Maps(M\to T))$,
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
    21
the singular chains on the space of maps from $M$ to $T$.
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
    22
(See Theorem \ref{thm:map-recon}.)
147
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 145
diff changeset
    23
\end{itemize}
481
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
    24
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    25
The blob complex definition is motivated by the desire for a derived analogue of the usual TQFT Hilbert space 
481
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
    26
(replacing the quotient of fields by local relations with some sort of resolution), 
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    27
and for a generalization of Hochschild homology to higher $n$-categories.
481
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
    28
One can think of it as the push-out of these two familiar constructions.
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
    29
More detailed motivations are described in \S \ref{sec:motivations}.
147
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 145
diff changeset
    30
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    31
The blob complex has good formal properties, summarized in \S \ref{sec:properties}.
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    32
These include an action of $\CH{M}$, 
481
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
    33
extending the usual $\Homeo(M)$ action on the TQFT space $H_0$ (Theorem \ref{thm:evaluation}) and a gluing 
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
    34
formula allowing calculations by cutting manifolds into smaller parts (Theorem \ref{thm:gluing}).
147
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 145
diff changeset
    35
481
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
    36
We expect applications of the blob complex to contact topology and Khovanov homology 
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
    37
but do not address these in this paper.
522
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 491
diff changeset
    38
%See \S \ref{sec:future} for slightly more detail.
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 491
diff changeset
    39
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 491
diff changeset
    40
Throughout, we have resisted the temptation to work in the greatest possible generality.
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 491
diff changeset
    41
(Don't worry, it wasn't that hard.)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 491
diff changeset
    42
In most of the places where we say ``set" or ``vector space", any symmetric monoidal category 
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 491
diff changeset
    43
with sufficient limits and colimits would do.
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 491
diff changeset
    44
We could also replace many of our chain complexes with topological spaces (or indeed, work at the generality of model categories).
147
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 145
diff changeset
    45
481
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
    46
415
8dedd2914d10 starting to revise ncat section
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 411
diff changeset
    47
\subsection{Structure of the paper}
400
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
    48
The subsections of the introduction explain our motivations in defining the blob complex (see \S \ref{sec:motivations}), 
522
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 491
diff changeset
    49
summarize the formal properties of the blob complex (see \S \ref{sec:properties}), describe known specializations (see \S \ref{sec:specializations}), and outline the major results of the paper (see \S \ref{sec:structure} and \S \ref{sec:applications}).
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 491
diff changeset
    50
%and outline anticipated future directions (see \S \ref{sec:future}).
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 491
diff changeset
    51
%\nn{recheck this list after done editing intro}
151
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 150
diff changeset
    52
551
9dfb5db2acd7 remaining changes from tuesday afternoon
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 550
diff changeset
    53
The first part of the paper (sections \S \ref{sec:fields}--\S \ref{sec:evaluation}) gives the definition of the blob complex, 
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    54
and establishes some of its properties.
481
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
    55
There are many alternative definitions of $n$-categories, and part of the challenge of defining the blob complex is 
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    56
simply explaining what we mean by an ``$n$-category with strong duality'' as one of the inputs.
417
d3b05641e7ca making quotation marks consistently "American style"
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 415
diff changeset
    57
At first we entirely avoid this problem by introducing the notion of a ``system of fields", and define the blob complex 
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    58
associated to an $n$-manifold and an $n$-dimensional system of fields.
481
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
    59
We sketch the construction of a system of fields from a *-$1$-category and from a pivotal $2$-category.
147
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 145
diff changeset
    60
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    61
Nevertheless, when we attempt to establish all of the observed properties of the blob complex, 
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    62
we find this situation unsatisfactory.
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    63
Thus, in the second part of the paper (\S\S \ref{sec:ncats}-\ref{sec:ainfblob}) we give yet another 
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    64
definition of an $n$-category, or rather a definition of an $n$-category with strong duality.
481
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
    65
(Removing the duality conditions from our definition would make it more complicated rather than less.) 
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    66
We call these ``topological $n$-categories'', to differentiate them from previous versions.
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    67
Moreover, we find that we need analogous $A_\infty$ $n$-categories, and we define these as well following very similar axioms.
147
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 145
diff changeset
    68
417
d3b05641e7ca making quotation marks consistently "American style"
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 415
diff changeset
    69
The basic idea is that each potential definition of an $n$-category makes a choice about the ``shape" of morphisms.
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    70
We try to be as lax as possible: a topological $n$-category associates a vector space to every $B$ homeomorphic to the $n$-ball.
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    71
These vector spaces glue together associatively, and we require that there is an action of the homeomorphism groupoid.
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    72
For an $A_\infty$ $n$-category, we associate a chain complex instead of a vector space to each such $B$ and ask that the action of 
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    73
homeomorphisms extends to a suitably defined action of the complex of singular chains of homeomorphisms.
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    74
The axioms for an $A_\infty$ $n$-category are designed to capture two main examples: the blob complexes of $n$-balls labelled by a 
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    75
topological $n$-category, and the complex $\CM{-}{T}$ of maps to a fixed target space $T$.
147
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 145
diff changeset
    76
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    77
In \S \ref{ss:ncat_fields}  we explain how to construct a system of fields from a topological $n$-category 
481
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
    78
(using a colimit along certain decompositions of a manifold into balls). 
528
96ec10a46ee1 minor; resolving a few \nns
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 526
diff changeset
    79
With this in hand, we write $\bc_*(M; \cC)$ to indicate the blob complex of a manifold $M$ 
481
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
    80
with the system of fields constructed from the $n$-category $\cC$. 
528
96ec10a46ee1 minor; resolving a few \nns
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 526
diff changeset
    81
%\nn{KW: I don't think we use this notational convention any more, right?}
481
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
    82
In \S \ref{sec:ainfblob} we give an alternative definition 
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    83
of the blob complex for an $A_\infty$ $n$-category on an $n$-manifold (analogously, using a homotopy colimit).
417
d3b05641e7ca making quotation marks consistently "American style"
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 415
diff changeset
    84
Using these definitions, we show how to use the blob complex to ``resolve" any topological $n$-category as an 
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    85
$A_\infty$ $n$-category, and relate the first and second definitions of the blob complex.
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
    86
We use the blob complex for $A_\infty$ $n$-categories to establish important properties of the blob complex (in both variants), 
417
d3b05641e7ca making quotation marks consistently "American style"
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 415
diff changeset
    87
in particular the ``gluing formula" of Theorem \ref{thm:gluing} below.
313
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 307
diff changeset
    88
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 307
diff changeset
    89
The relationship between all these ideas is sketched in Figure \ref{fig:outline}.
150
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 148
diff changeset
    90
307
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
    91
\tikzstyle{box} = [rectangle, rounded corners, draw,outer sep = 5pt, inner sep = 5pt, line width=0.5pt]
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
    92
313
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 307
diff changeset
    93
\begin{figure}[!ht]
307
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
    94
{\center
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
    95
561
77a80f91e214 last minute changes from friday, to submit to the arxiv
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 558
diff changeset
    96
\beginpgfgraphicnamed{gadgets-external}%
307
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
    97
\begin{tikzpicture}[align=center,line width = 1.5pt]
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
    98
\newcommand{\xa}{2}
485
cd66f8e3ae44 tweaks to intro: adding traditional n-categories to the diagram of gadgets, rearranging mention of exactness
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 484
diff changeset
    99
\newcommand{\xb}{8}
307
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
   100
\newcommand{\ya}{14}
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
   101
\newcommand{\yb}{10}
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
   102
\newcommand{\yc}{6}
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
   103
485
cd66f8e3ae44 tweaks to intro: adding traditional n-categories to the diagram of gadgets, rearranging mention of exactness
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 484
diff changeset
   104
\node[box] at (-4,\yb) (tC) {$C$ \\ a `traditional' \\ weak $n$-category};
307
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
   105
\node[box] at (\xa,\ya) (C) {$\cC$ \\ a topological \\ $n$-category};
319
121c580d5ef7 editting all over the place
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 314
diff changeset
   106
\node[box] at (\xb,\ya) (A) {$\underrightarrow{\cC}(M)$ \\ the (dual) TQFT \\ Hilbert space};
491
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 489
diff changeset
   107
\node[box] at (\xa,\yb) (FU) {$(\cF, U)$ \\ fields and\\ local relations};
489
bdbd890086eb trying to talk about restrictions to twig blobs precisely, but the currently text is clunky
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 485
diff changeset
   108
\node[box] at (\xb,\yb) (BC) {$\bc_*(M; \cF)$ \\ the blob complex};
307
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
   109
\node[box] at (\xa,\yc) (Cs) {$\cC_*$ \\ an $A_\infty$ \\$n$-category};
319
121c580d5ef7 editting all over the place
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 314
diff changeset
   110
\node[box] at (\xb,\yc) (BCs) {$\underrightarrow{\cC_*}(M)$};
307
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
   111
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
   112
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
   113
314
6e23226d1cca various small changes
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 313
diff changeset
   114
\draw[->] (C) -- node[above] {$\displaystyle \colim_{\cell(M)} \cC$} node[below] {\S\S \ref{sec:constructing-a-tqft} \& \ref{ss:ncat_fields}} (A);
307
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
   115
\draw[->] (FU) -- node[below] {blob complex \\ for $M$} (BC);
314
6e23226d1cca various small changes
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 313
diff changeset
   116
\draw[->] (Cs) -- node[above] {$\displaystyle \hocolim_{\cell(M)} \cC_*$} node[below] {\S \ref{ss:ncat_fields}} (BCs);
307
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
   117
491
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 489
diff changeset
   118
\draw[->] (FU) -- node[right=10pt] {$\cF(M)/U$} (A);
307
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
   119
485
cd66f8e3ae44 tweaks to intro: adding traditional n-categories to the diagram of gadgets, rearranging mention of exactness
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 484
diff changeset
   120
\draw[->] (tC) -- node[above] {Example \ref{ex:traditional-n-categories(fields)}} (FU);
cd66f8e3ae44 tweaks to intro: adding traditional n-categories to the diagram of gadgets, rearranging mention of exactness
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 484
diff changeset
   121
cd66f8e3ae44 tweaks to intro: adding traditional n-categories to the diagram of gadgets, rearranging mention of exactness
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 484
diff changeset
   122
\draw[->] (C.-100) -- node[left] {
cd66f8e3ae44 tweaks to intro: adding traditional n-categories to the diagram of gadgets, rearranging mention of exactness
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 484
diff changeset
   123
	\S \ref{ss:ncat_fields}
491
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 489
diff changeset
   124
	%$\displaystyle \cF(M) = \DirectSum_{c \in\cell(M)} \cC(c)$ \\ $\displaystyle U(B) = \DirectSum_{c \in \cell(B)} \ker \ev: \cC(c) \to \cC(B)$
485
cd66f8e3ae44 tweaks to intro: adding traditional n-categories to the diagram of gadgets, rearranging mention of exactness
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 484
diff changeset
   125
   } (FU.100);
cd66f8e3ae44 tweaks to intro: adding traditional n-categories to the diagram of gadgets, rearranging mention of exactness
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 484
diff changeset
   126
\draw[->] (C) -- node[above left=3pt] {restrict to \\ standard balls} (tC);
cd66f8e3ae44 tweaks to intro: adding traditional n-categories to the diagram of gadgets, rearranging mention of exactness
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 484
diff changeset
   127
\draw[->] (FU.80) -- node[right] {restrict \\ to balls} (C.-80);
550
c9f41c18a96f deleting nn's
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 536
diff changeset
   128
\draw[->] (BC) -- node[right] {$H_0$ \\ c.f. Proposition \ref{thm:skein-modules}} (A);
307
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
   129
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
   130
\draw[->] (FU) -- node[left] {blob complex \\ for balls} (Cs);
528
96ec10a46ee1 minor; resolving a few \nns
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 526
diff changeset
   131
\draw[<->] (BC) -- node[right] {$\iso$ by \\ Corollary \ref{cor:new-old}} (BCs);
307
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
   132
\end{tikzpicture}
561
77a80f91e214 last minute changes from friday, to submit to the arxiv
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 558
diff changeset
   133
\endpgfgraphicnamed{gadgets-external}%
307
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
   134
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
   135
}
313
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 307
diff changeset
   136
\caption{The main gadgets and constructions of the paper.}
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 307
diff changeset
   137
\label{fig:outline}
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 307
diff changeset
   138
\end{figure}
307
285b2a29dff0 diagram for introduction
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 292
diff changeset
   139
558
c393d1202724 added abstract; other misc minor stuff
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 556
diff changeset
   140
Later sections address other topics.
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   141
Section \S \ref{sec:deligne} gives
481
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
   142
a higher dimensional generalization of the Deligne conjecture 
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
   143
(that the little discs operad acts on Hochschild cochains) in terms of the blob complex.
528
96ec10a46ee1 minor; resolving a few \nns
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 526
diff changeset
   144
The appendices prove technical results about $\CH{M}$ and
96ec10a46ee1 minor; resolving a few \nns
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 526
diff changeset
   145
make connections between our definitions of $n$-categories and familiar definitions for $n=1$ and $n=2$, 
481
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
   146
as well as relating the $n=1$ case of our $A_\infty$ $n$-categories with usual $A_\infty$ algebras. 
553
94cadcb4831f killing commutative alg appendix
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 551
diff changeset
   147
%Appendix \ref{sec:comm_alg} describes the blob complex when $\cC$ is a commutative algebra, 
94cadcb4831f killing commutative alg appendix
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 551
diff changeset
   148
%thought of as a topological $n$-category, in terms of the topology of $M$.
150
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 148
diff changeset
   149
482
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   150
%%%% this is said later in the intro
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   151
%Throughout the paper we typically prefer concrete categories (vector spaces, chain complexes)
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   152
%even when we could work in greater generality (symmetric monoidal categories, model categories, etc.).
131
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 117
diff changeset
   153
481
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
   154
%\item ? one of the points we make (far) below is that there is not really much
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
   155
%difference between (a) systems of fields and local relations and (b) $n$-cats;
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
   156
%thus we tend to switch between talking in terms of one or the other
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
   157
7caafccef7e8 starting to revise intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 464
diff changeset
   158
131
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 117
diff changeset
   159
151
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 150
diff changeset
   160
\subsection{Motivations}
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 150
diff changeset
   161
\label{sec:motivations}
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 150
diff changeset
   162
160
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 155
diff changeset
   163
We will briefly sketch our original motivation for defining the blob complex.
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 155
diff changeset
   164
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 155
diff changeset
   165
As a starting point, consider TQFTs constructed via fields and local relations.
426
8aca80203f9d search & replace: s/((sub?)section|appendix)\s+\\ref/\S\ref/
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 417
diff changeset
   166
(See \S\ref{sec:tqftsviafields} or \cite{kw:tqft}.)
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   167
This gives a satisfactory treatment for semisimple TQFTs
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   168
(i.e.\ TQFTs for which the cylinder 1-category associated to an
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   169
$n{-}1$-manifold $Y$ is semisimple for all $Y$).
160
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 155
diff changeset
   170
166
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 163
diff changeset
   171
For non-semi-simple TQFTs, this approach is less satisfactory.
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   172
Our main motivating example (though we will not develop it in this paper)
160
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 155
diff changeset
   173
is the (decapitated) $4{+}1$-dimensional TQFT associated to Khovanov homology.
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   174
It associates a bigraded vector space $A_{Kh}(W^4, L)$ to a 4-manifold $W$ together
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   175
with a link $L \subset \bd W$.
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   176
The original Khovanov homology of a link in $S^3$ is recovered as $A_{Kh}(B^4, L)$.
482
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   177
%\todo{I'm tempted to replace $A_{Kh}$ with $\cl{Kh}$ throughout this page -S}
160
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 155
diff changeset
   178
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 155
diff changeset
   179
How would we go about computing $A_{Kh}(W^4, L)$?
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   180
For the Khovanov homology of a link in $S^3$ the main tool is the exact triangle (long exact sequence)
166
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 163
diff changeset
   181
relating resolutions of a crossing.
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   182
Unfortunately, the exactness breaks if we glue $B^4$ to itself and attempt
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   183
to compute $A_{Kh}(S^1\times B^3, L)$.
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   184
According to the gluing theorem for TQFTs, gluing along $B^3 \subset \bd B^4$
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   185
corresponds to taking a coend (self tensor product) over the cylinder category
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   186
associated to $B^3$ (with appropriate boundary conditions).
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   187
The coend is not an exact functor, so the exactness of the triangle breaks.
160
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 155
diff changeset
   188
482
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   189
The obvious solution to this problem is to replace the coend with its derived counterpart, 
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   190
Hochschild homology.
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   191
This presumably works fine for $S^1\times B^3$ (the answer being the Hochschild homology
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   192
of an appropriate bimodule), but for more complicated 4-manifolds this leaves much to be desired.
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   193
If we build our manifold up via a handle decomposition, the computation
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   194
would be a sequence of derived coends.
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   195
A different handle decomposition of the same manifold would yield a different
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   196
sequence of derived coends.
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   197
To show that our definition in terms of derived coends is well-defined, we
482
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   198
would need to show that the above two sequences of derived coends yield 
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   199
isomorphic answers, and that the isomorphism does not depend on any
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   200
choices we made along the way.
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   201
This is probably not easy to do.
160
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 155
diff changeset
   202
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 155
diff changeset
   203
Instead, we would prefer a definition for a derived version of $A_{Kh}(W^4, L)$
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   204
which is manifestly invariant.
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   205
(That is, a definition that does not
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   206
involve choosing a decomposition of $W$.
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   207
After all, one of the virtues of our starting point --- TQFTs via field and local relations ---
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   208
is that it has just this sort of manifest invariance.)
160
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 155
diff changeset
   209
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 155
diff changeset
   210
The solution is to replace $A_{Kh}(W^4, L)$, which is a quotient
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   211
\[
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   212
 \text{linear combinations of fields} \;\big/\; \text{local relations} ,
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   213
\]
482
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   214
with an appropriately free resolution (the blob complex)
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   215
\[
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   216
	\cdots\to \bc_2(W, L) \to \bc_1(W, L) \to \bc_0(W, L) .
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   217
\]
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   218
Here $\bc_0$ is linear combinations of fields on $W$,
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   219
$\bc_1$ is linear combinations of local relations on $W$,
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   220
$\bc_2$ is linear combinations of relations amongst relations on $W$,
485
cd66f8e3ae44 tweaks to intro: adding traditional n-categories to the diagram of gadgets, rearranging mention of exactness
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 484
diff changeset
   221
and so on. We now have a short exact sequence of chain complexes relating resolutions of the link $L$ (c.f. Lemma \ref{lem:hochschild-exact} which shows exactness with respect to boundary conditions in the context of Hochschild homology).
160
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 155
diff changeset
   222
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   223
147
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 145
diff changeset
   224
\subsection{Formal properties}
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 145
diff changeset
   225
\label{sec:properties}
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   226
The blob complex enjoys the following list of formal properties.
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   227
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   228
\begin{property}[Functoriality]
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   229
\label{property:functoriality}%
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   230
The blob complex is functorial with respect to homeomorphisms.
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   231
That is, 
464
6c760675d461 fiddling inconclusively with 'decomposition into balls'
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 454
diff changeset
   232
for a fixed $n$-dimensional system of fields $\cF$, the association
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   233
\begin{equation*}
464
6c760675d461 fiddling inconclusively with 'decomposition into balls'
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 454
diff changeset
   234
X \mapsto \bc_*(X; \cF)
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   235
\end{equation*}
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   236
is a functor from $n$-manifolds and homeomorphisms between them to chain 
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   237
complexes and isomorphisms between them.
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   238
\end{property}
464
6c760675d461 fiddling inconclusively with 'decomposition into balls'
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 454
diff changeset
   239
As a consequence, there is an action of $\Homeo(X)$ on the chain complex $\bc_*(X; \cF)$; 
400
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   240
this action is extended to all of $C_*(\Homeo(X))$ in Theorem \ref{thm:evaluation} below.
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   241
485
cd66f8e3ae44 tweaks to intro: adding traditional n-categories to the diagram of gadgets, rearranging mention of exactness
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 484
diff changeset
   242
The blob complex is also functorial with respect to $\cF$, 
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   243
although we will not address this in detail here.
131
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 117
diff changeset
   244
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   245
\begin{property}[Disjoint union]
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   246
\label{property:disjoint-union}
482
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   247
The blob complex of a disjoint union is naturally isomorphic to the tensor product of the blob complexes.
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   248
\begin{equation*}
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   249
\bc_*(X_1 \du X_2) \iso \bc_*(X_1) \tensor \bc_*(X_2)
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   250
\end{equation*}
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   251
\end{property}
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   252
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   253
If an $n$-manifold $X$ contains $Y \sqcup Y^\text{op}$ as a codimension $0$ submanifold of its boundary, 
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   254
write $X_\text{gl} = X \bigcup_{Y}\selfarrow$ for the manifold obtained by gluing together $Y$ and $Y^\text{op}$.
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   255
Note that this includes the case of gluing two disjoint manifolds together.
131
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 117
diff changeset
   256
\begin{property}[Gluing map]
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   257
\label{property:gluing-map}%
136
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 132
diff changeset
   258
%If $X_1$ and $X_2$ are $n$-manifolds, with $Y$ a codimension $0$-submanifold of $\bdy X_1$, and $Y^{\text{op}}$ a codimension $0$-submanifold of $\bdy X_2$, there is a chain map
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 132
diff changeset
   259
%\begin{equation*}
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 132
diff changeset
   260
%\gl_Y: \bc_*(X_1) \tensor \bc_*(X_2) \to \bc_*(X_1 \cup_Y X_2).
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 132
diff changeset
   261
%\end{equation*}
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   262
Given a gluing $X \to X_\mathrm{gl}$, there is
131
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 117
diff changeset
   263
a natural map
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 117
diff changeset
   264
\[
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   265
	\bc_*(X) \to \bc_*(X_\mathrm{gl}) 
131
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 117
diff changeset
   266
\]
187
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 166
diff changeset
   267
(natural with respect to homeomorphisms, and also associative with respect to iterated gluings).
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   268
\end{property}
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   269
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   270
\begin{property}[Contractibility]
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   271
\label{property:contractibility}%
482
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   272
With field coefficients, the blob complex on an $n$-ball is contractible in the sense 
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   273
that it is homotopic to its $0$-th homology.
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   274
Moreover, the $0$-th homology of balls can be canonically identified with the vector spaces 
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   275
associated by the system of fields $\cF$ to balls.
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   276
\begin{equation*}
482
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   277
\xymatrix{\bc_*(B^n;\cF) \ar[r]^(0.4){\iso}_(0.4){\text{qi}} & H_0(\bc_*(B^n;\cF)) \ar[r]^(0.6)\iso & A_\cF(B^n)}
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   278
\end{equation*}
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   279
\end{property}
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   280
400
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   281
Properties \ref{property:functoriality} will be immediate from the definition given in
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   282
\S \ref{sec:blob-definition}, and we'll recall it at the appropriate point there.
482
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   283
Properties \ref{property:disjoint-union}, \ref{property:gluing-map} and 
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   284
\ref{property:contractibility} are established in \S \ref{sec:basic-properties}.
400
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   285
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   286
\subsection{Specializations}
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   287
\label{sec:specializations}
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   288
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   289
The blob complex is a simultaneous generalization of the TQFT skein module construction and of Hochschild homology.
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   290
550
c9f41c18a96f deleting nn's
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 536
diff changeset
   291
\newtheorem*{thm:skein-modules}{Proposition \ref{thm:skein-modules}}
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   292
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   293
\begin{thm:skein-modules}[Skein modules]
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   294
The $0$-th blob homology of $X$ is the usual 
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   295
(dual) TQFT Hilbert space (a.k.a.\ skein module) associated to $X$
464
6c760675d461 fiddling inconclusively with 'decomposition into balls'
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 454
diff changeset
   296
by $\cF$.
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   297
(See \S \ref{sec:local-relations}.)
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   298
\begin{equation*}
464
6c760675d461 fiddling inconclusively with 'decomposition into balls'
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 454
diff changeset
   299
H_0(\bc_*(X;\cF)) \iso A_{\cF}(X)
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   300
\end{equation*}
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   301
\end{thm:skein-modules}
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   302
400
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   303
\newtheorem*{thm:hochschild}{Theorem \ref{thm:hochschild}}
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   304
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   305
\begin{thm:hochschild}[Hochschild homology when $X=S^1$]
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   306
The blob complex for a $1$-category $\cC$ on the circle is
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   307
quasi-isomorphic to the Hochschild complex.
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   308
\begin{equation*}
482
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   309
\xymatrix{\bc_*(S^1;\cC) \ar[r]^(0.47){\iso}_(0.47){\text{qi}} & \HC_*(\cC).}
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   310
\end{equation*}
400
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   311
\end{thm:hochschild}
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   312
550
c9f41c18a96f deleting nn's
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 536
diff changeset
   313
Proposition \ref{thm:skein-modules} is immediate from the definition, and
400
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   314
Theorem \ref{thm:hochschild} is established in \S \ref{sec:hochschild}.
558
c393d1202724 added abstract; other misc minor stuff
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 556
diff changeset
   315
%We also note \S \ref{sec:comm_alg} which describes the blob complex when $\cC$ is a one of 
c393d1202724 added abstract; other misc minor stuff
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 556
diff changeset
   316
%certain commutative algebras thought of as $n$-categories.
400
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   317
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   318
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   319
\subsection{Structure of the blob complex}
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   320
\label{sec:structure}
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   321
191
8c2c330e87f2 working on ncats -- no new material, just improving text
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 187
diff changeset
   322
In the following $\CH{X}$ is the singular chain complex of the space of homeomorphisms of $X$, fixed on $\bdy X$.
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   323
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   324
\newtheorem*{thm:CH}{Theorem \ref{thm:CH}}
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   325
454
3377d4db80d9 removing superscripts from \bc
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 437
diff changeset
   326
\begin{thm:CH}[$C_*(\Homeo(-))$ action]
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   327
There is a chain map
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   328
\begin{equation*}
482
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   329
e_X: \CH{X} \tensor \bc_*(X) \to \bc_*(X).
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   330
\end{equation*}
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   331
such that
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   332
\begin{enumerate}
313
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 307
diff changeset
   333
\item Restricted to $C_0(\Homeo(X))$ this is the action of homeomorphisms described in Property \ref{property:functoriality}. 
191
8c2c330e87f2 working on ncats -- no new material, just improving text
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 187
diff changeset
   334
313
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 307
diff changeset
   335
\item For
147
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 145
diff changeset
   336
any codimension $0$-submanifold $Y \sqcup Y^\text{op} \subset \bdy X$ the following diagram
313
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 307
diff changeset
   337
(using the gluing maps described in Property \ref{property:gluing-map}) commutes (up to homotopy).
147
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 145
diff changeset
   338
\begin{equation*}
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 145
diff changeset
   339
\xymatrix@C+2cm{
166
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 163
diff changeset
   340
     \CH{X} \otimes \bc_*(X)
482
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   341
        \ar[r]_{e_{X}}  \ar[d]^{\gl^{\Homeo}_Y \otimes \gl_Y}  &
454
3377d4db80d9 removing superscripts from \bc
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 437
diff changeset
   342
            \bc_*(X) \ar[d]_{\gl_Y} \\
482
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   343
     \CH{X \bigcup_Y \selfarrow} \otimes \bc_*(X \bigcup_Y \selfarrow) \ar[r]^<<<<<<<<<<<<{e_{(X \bigcup_Y \scalebox{0.5}{\selfarrow})}}    & \bc_*(X \bigcup_Y \selfarrow)
147
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 145
diff changeset
   344
}
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 145
diff changeset
   345
\end{equation*}
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   346
\end{enumerate}
528
96ec10a46ee1 minor; resolving a few \nns
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 526
diff changeset
   347
%Moreover any such chain map is unique, up to an iterated homotopy.
96ec10a46ee1 minor; resolving a few \nns
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 526
diff changeset
   348
%(That is, any pair of homotopies have a homotopy between them, and so on.)
96ec10a46ee1 minor; resolving a few \nns
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 526
diff changeset
   349
%\nn{revisit this after proof below has stabilized}
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   350
\end{thm:CH}
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   351
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   352
\newtheorem*{thm:CH-associativity}{Theorem \ref{thm:CH-associativity}}
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   353
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   354
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   355
Further,
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   356
\begin{thm:CH-associativity}
454
3377d4db80d9 removing superscripts from \bc
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 437
diff changeset
   357
The chain map of Theorem \ref{thm:CH} is associative, in the sense that the following diagram commutes (up to homotopy).
313
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 307
diff changeset
   358
\begin{equation*}
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 307
diff changeset
   359
\xymatrix{
482
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   360
\CH{X} \tensor \CH{X} \tensor \bc_*(X) \ar[r]^<<<<<{\id \tensor e_X} \ar[d]^{\compose \tensor \id} & \CH{X} \tensor \bc_*(X) \ar[d]^{e_X} \\
6ba3a46a0b50 more revisions of intro
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 481
diff changeset
   361
\CH{X} \tensor \bc_*(X) \ar[r]^{e_X} & \bc_*(X)
313
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 307
diff changeset
   362
}
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 307
diff changeset
   363
\end{equation*}
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   364
\end{thm:CH-associativity}
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   365
313
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 307
diff changeset
   366
Since the blob complex is functorial in the manifold $X$, this is equivalent to having chain maps
191
8c2c330e87f2 working on ncats -- no new material, just improving text
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 187
diff changeset
   367
$$ev_{X \to Y} : \CH{X \to Y} \tensor \bc_*(X) \to \bc_*(Y)$$
313
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 307
diff changeset
   368
for any homeomorphic pair $X$ and $Y$, 
191
8c2c330e87f2 working on ncats -- no new material, just improving text
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 187
diff changeset
   369
satisfying corresponding conditions.
8c2c330e87f2 working on ncats -- no new material, just improving text
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 187
diff changeset
   370
536
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 528
diff changeset
   371
In \S \ref{sec:ncats} we introduce the notion of topological $n$-categories, from which we can construct systems of fields.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 528
diff changeset
   372
Below, when we talk about the blob complex for a topological $n$-category, we are implicitly passing first to this associated system of fields.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 528
diff changeset
   373
Further, in \S \ref{sec:ncats} we also have the notion of an $A_\infty$ $n$-category. In that section we describe how to use the blob complex to construct $A_\infty$ $n$-categories from topological $n$-categories:
484
ace8913f02a5 done with intro for now
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 483
diff changeset
   374
536
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 528
diff changeset
   375
\newtheorem*{ex:blob-complexes-of-balls}{Example \ref{ex:blob-complexes-of-balls}}
151
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 150
diff changeset
   376
536
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 528
diff changeset
   377
\begin{ex:blob-complexes-of-balls}[Blob complexes of products with balls form an $A_\infty$ $n$-category]
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 528
diff changeset
   378
%\label{thm:blobs-ainfty}
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   379
Let $\cC$ be  a topological $n$-category.
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   380
Let $Y$ be an $n{-}k$-manifold. 
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   381
There is an $A_\infty$ $k$-category $\bc_*(Y;\cC)$, defined on each $m$-ball $D$, for $0 \leq m < k$, 
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   382
to be the set $$\bc_*(Y;\cC)(D) = \cC(Y \times D)$$ and on $k$-balls $D$ to be the set 
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   383
$$\bc_*(Y;\cC)(D) = \bc_*(Y \times D; \cC).$$ 
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   384
(When $m=k$ the subsets with fixed boundary conditions form a chain complex.) 
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   385
These sets have the structure of an $A_\infty$ $k$-category, with compositions coming from the gluing map in 
400
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   386
Property \ref{property:gluing-map} and with the action of families of homeomorphisms given in Theorem \ref{thm:evaluation}.
536
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 528
diff changeset
   387
\end{ex:blob-complexes-of-balls}
151
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 150
diff changeset
   388
\begin{rem}
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   389
Perhaps the most interesting case is when $Y$ is just a point; then we have a way of building an $A_\infty$ $n$-category from a topological $n$-category.
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   390
We think of this $A_\infty$ $n$-category as a free resolution.
151
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 150
diff changeset
   391
\end{rem}
484
ace8913f02a5 done with intro for now
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 483
diff changeset
   392
136
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 132
diff changeset
   393
There is a version of the blob complex for $\cC$ an $A_\infty$ $n$-category
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   394
instead of a topological $n$-category; this is described in \S \ref{sec:ainfblob}.
536
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 528
diff changeset
   395
The definition is in fact simpler, almost tautological, and we use a different notation, $\cl{\cC}(M)$. The next theorem describes the blob complex for product manifolds, in terms of the $A_\infty$ blob complex of the $A_\infty$ $n$-categories constructed as in the previous example.
484
ace8913f02a5 done with intro for now
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 483
diff changeset
   396
%The notation is intended to reflect the close parallel with the definition of the TQFT skein module via a colimit.
136
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 132
diff changeset
   397
400
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   398
\newtheorem*{thm:product}{Theorem \ref{thm:product}}
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   399
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   400
\begin{thm:product}[Product formula]
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   401
Let $W$ be a $k$-manifold and $Y$ be an $n-k$ manifold.
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   402
Let $\cC$ be an $n$-category.
536
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 528
diff changeset
   403
Let $\bc_*(Y;\cC)$ be the $A_\infty$ $k$-category associated to $Y$ via blob homology (see Example \ref{ex:blob-complexes-of-balls}).
136
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 132
diff changeset
   404
Then
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 132
diff changeset
   405
\[
338
adc0780aa5e7 updating notation in intro, also deciding that not everything is a 'property'
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 332
diff changeset
   406
	\bc_*(Y\times W; \cC) \simeq \cl{\bc_*(Y;\cC)}(W).
136
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 132
diff changeset
   407
\]
400
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   408
\end{thm:product}
484
ace8913f02a5 done with intro for now
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 483
diff changeset
   409
The statement can be generalized to arbitrary fibre bundles, and indeed to arbitrary maps
526
803cc581fd42 revisions of evmap; misc
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 522
diff changeset
   410
(see \S \ref{ss:product-formula}).
338
adc0780aa5e7 updating notation in intro, also deciding that not everything is a 'property'
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 332
diff changeset
   411
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   412
Fix a topological $n$-category $\cC$, which we'll omit from the notation.
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   413
Recall that for any $(n-1)$-manifold $Y$, the blob complex $\bc_*(Y)$ is naturally an $A_\infty$ category.
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   414
(See Appendix \ref{sec:comparing-A-infty} for the translation between topological $A_\infty$ $1$-categories and the usual algebraic notion of an $A_\infty$ category.)
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   415
400
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   416
\newtheorem*{thm:gluing}{Theorem \ref{thm:gluing}}
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   417
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   418
\begin{thm:gluing}[Gluing formula]
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   419
\mbox{}% <-- gets the indenting right
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   420
\begin{itemize}
222
217b6a870532 committing changes from loon lake - mostly small blobs
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 217
diff changeset
   421
\item For any $n$-manifold $X$, with $Y$ a codimension $0$-submanifold of its boundary, the blob complex of $X$ is naturally an
338
adc0780aa5e7 updating notation in intro, also deciding that not everything is a 'property'
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 332
diff changeset
   422
$A_\infty$ module for $\bc_*(Y)$.
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   423
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   424
\item For any $n$-manifold $X_\text{gl} = X\bigcup_Y \selfarrow$, the blob complex $\bc_*(X_\text{gl})$ is the $A_\infty$ self-tensor product of
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   425
$\bc_*(X)$ as an $\bc_*(Y)$-bimodule:
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   426
\begin{equation*}
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   427
\bc_*(X_\text{gl}) \simeq \bc_*(X) \Tensor^{A_\infty}_{\mathclap{\bc_*(Y)}} \selfarrow
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   428
\end{equation*}
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   429
\end{itemize}
400
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   430
\end{thm:gluing}
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   431
484
ace8913f02a5 done with intro for now
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 483
diff changeset
   432
Theorem \ref{thm:product} is proved in \S \ref{ss:product-formula}, and Theorem \ref{thm:gluing} in \S \ref{sec:gluing}.
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   433
400
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   434
\subsection{Applications}
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   435
\label{sec:applications}
556
4f008d0a29d4 fat graph -> surgery cylinder
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 553
diff changeset
   436
Finally, we give two applications of the above machinery.
117
b62214646c4f preparing for semi-public version soon
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 98
diff changeset
   437
400
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   438
\newtheorem*{thm:map-recon}{Theorem \ref{thm:map-recon}}
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   439
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   440
\begin{thm:map-recon}[Mapping spaces]
187
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 166
diff changeset
   441
Let $\pi^\infty_{\le n}(T)$ denote the $A_\infty$ $n$-category based on maps 
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 166
diff changeset
   442
$B^n \to T$.
222
217b6a870532 committing changes from loon lake - mostly small blobs
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 217
diff changeset
   443
(The case $n=1$ is the usual $A_\infty$-category of paths in $T$.)
136
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 132
diff changeset
   444
Then 
484
ace8913f02a5 done with intro for now
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 483
diff changeset
   445
$$\bc_*(X; \pi^\infty_{\le n}(T)) \simeq \CM{X}{T}.$$
400
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   446
\end{thm:map-recon}
117
b62214646c4f preparing for semi-public version soon
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 98
diff changeset
   447
484
ace8913f02a5 done with intro for now
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 483
diff changeset
   448
This says that we can recover (up to homotopy) the space of maps to $T$ via blob homology from local data. 
556
4f008d0a29d4 fat graph -> surgery cylinder
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 553
diff changeset
   449
Note that there is no restriction on the connectivity of $T$.
484
ace8913f02a5 done with intro for now
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 483
diff changeset
   450
The proof appears in \S \ref{sec:map-recon}.
187
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 166
diff changeset
   451
400
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   452
\newtheorem*{thm:deligne}{Theorem \ref{thm:deligne}}
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   453
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   454
\begin{thm:deligne}[Higher dimensional Deligne conjecture]
556
4f008d0a29d4 fat graph -> surgery cylinder
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 553
diff changeset
   455
The singular chains of the $n$-dimensional surgery cylinder operad act on blob cochains.
4f008d0a29d4 fat graph -> surgery cylinder
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 553
diff changeset
   456
Since the little $n{+}1$-balls operad is a suboperad of the $n$-dimensional surgery cylinder operad,
4f008d0a29d4 fat graph -> surgery cylinder
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 553
diff changeset
   457
this implies that the little $n{+}1$-balls operad acts on blob cochains of the $n$-ball.
400
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   458
\end{thm:deligne}
484
ace8913f02a5 done with intro for now
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 483
diff changeset
   459
See \S \ref{sec:deligne} for a full explanation of the statement, and the proof.
98
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents:
diff changeset
   460
400
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   461
a02a6158f3bd Breaking up 'properties' in the intro into smaller subsections, converting many properties back to theorems, and numbering according to where they occur in the text. Not completely done, e.g. the action map which needs statements made consistent.
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 340
diff changeset
   462
556
4f008d0a29d4 fat graph -> surgery cylinder
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 553
diff changeset
   463
\noop{ %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
148
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 147
diff changeset
   464
\subsection{Future directions}
151
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 150
diff changeset
   465
\label{sec:future}
484
ace8913f02a5 done with intro for now
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 483
diff changeset
   466
\nn{KW: Perhaps we should delete this subsection and salvage only the first few sentences.}
ace8913f02a5 done with intro for now
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 483
diff changeset
   467
Throughout, we have resisted the temptation to work in the greatest generality possible.
ace8913f02a5 done with intro for now
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 483
diff changeset
   468
(Don't worry, it wasn't that hard.)
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   469
In most of the places where we say ``set" or ``vector space", any symmetric monoidal category would do.
484
ace8913f02a5 done with intro for now
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 483
diff changeset
   470
We could also replace many of our chain complexes with topological spaces (or indeed, work at the generality of model categories).
ace8913f02a5 done with intro for now
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 483
diff changeset
   471
%%%%%%
ace8913f02a5 done with intro for now
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 483
diff changeset
   472
And likely it will prove useful to think about the connections between what we do here and $(\infty,k)$-categories.
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   473
More could be said about finite characteristic 
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   474
(there appears in be $2$-torsion in $\bc_1(S^2; \cC)$ for any spherical $2$-category $\cC$, for example).
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   475
Much more could be said about other types of manifolds, in particular oriented, 
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   476
$\operatorname{Spin}$ and $\operatorname{Pin}^{\pm}$ manifolds, where boundary issues become more complicated.
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   477
(We'd recommend thinking about boundaries as germs, rather than just codimension $1$ manifolds.) 
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   478
We've also take the path of least resistance by considering $\operatorname{PL}$ manifolds; 
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   479
there may be some differences for topological manifolds and smooth manifolds.
148
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 147
diff changeset
   480
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   481
The paper ``Skein homology'' \cite{MR1624157} has similar motivations, and it may be 
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   482
interesting to investigate if there is a connection with the material here.
314
6e23226d1cca various small changes
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 313
diff changeset
   483
417
d3b05641e7ca making quotation marks consistently "American style"
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 415
diff changeset
   484
Many results in Hochschild homology can be understood ``topologically" via the blob complex.
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   485
For example, we expect that the shuffle product on the Hochschild homology of a commutative algebra $A$ 
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   486
(see \cite[\S 4.2]{MR1600246}) simply corresponds to the gluing operation on $\bc_*(S^1 \times [0,1]; A)$, 
340
f7da004e1f14 breaking long lines (probably a waste of time, but I couldn't resist)
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 338
diff changeset
   487
but haven't investigated the details.
148
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 147
diff changeset
   488
437
93ce0ba3d2d7 revisions to \S 1-5
Scott Morrison <scott@tqft.net>
parents: 426
diff changeset
   489
Most importantly, however, \nn{applications!} \nn{cyclic homology, $n=2$ cases, contact, Kh} \nn{stabilization} \nn{stable categories, generalized cohomology theories}
556
4f008d0a29d4 fat graph -> surgery cylinder
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 553
diff changeset
   490
} %%% end \noop %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
148
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 147
diff changeset
   491
scott@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 147
diff changeset
   492
\subsection{Thanks and acknowledgements}
411
98b8559b0b7a starting to work on tqdftreview.tex
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 407
diff changeset
   493
% attempting to make this chronological rather than alphabetical
98b8559b0b7a starting to work on tqdftreview.tex
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 407
diff changeset
   494
We'd like to thank 
98b8559b0b7a starting to work on tqdftreview.tex
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 407
diff changeset
   495
Justin Roberts, 
98b8559b0b7a starting to work on tqdftreview.tex
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 407
diff changeset
   496
Michael Freedman, 
98b8559b0b7a starting to work on tqdftreview.tex
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 407
diff changeset
   497
Peter Teichner, 
98b8559b0b7a starting to work on tqdftreview.tex
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 407
diff changeset
   498
David Ben-Zvi, 
98b8559b0b7a starting to work on tqdftreview.tex
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 407
diff changeset
   499
Vaughan Jones, 
98b8559b0b7a starting to work on tqdftreview.tex
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 407
diff changeset
   500
Chris Schommer-Pries, 
98b8559b0b7a starting to work on tqdftreview.tex
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 407
diff changeset
   501
Thomas Tradler,
98b8559b0b7a starting to work on tqdftreview.tex
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 407
diff changeset
   502
Kevin Costello, 
98b8559b0b7a starting to work on tqdftreview.tex
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 407
diff changeset
   503
Chris Douglas,
98b8559b0b7a starting to work on tqdftreview.tex
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 407
diff changeset
   504
and
98b8559b0b7a starting to work on tqdftreview.tex
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 407
diff changeset
   505
Alexander Kirillov
98b8559b0b7a starting to work on tqdftreview.tex
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 407
diff changeset
   506
for many interesting and useful conversations. 
522
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 491
diff changeset
   507
During this work, Kevin Walker has been at Microsoft Station Q, and Scott Morrison has been at Microsoft Station Q and the Miller Institute for Basic Research at UC Berkeley. We'd like to thank the Aspen Center for Physics for the pleasant and productive 
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 491
diff changeset
   508
% "conducive" needs an object; "conducive to blah"
Kevin Walker <kevin@canyon23.net>
parents: 491
diff changeset
   509
environment provided there during the final preparation of this manuscript.
155
kevin@6e1638ff-ae45-0410-89bd-df963105f760
parents: 151
diff changeset
   510